Part I. The usual suspects -- Dominic -- Andrew -- Allison -- Numbers -- Maria -- Lupita -- Ashley -- Sal -- Connie -- Part II. Suburban noir -- The third man -- Shadow of a doubt -- I confess -- Rear window -- The man who knew too much -- Strangers on a train -- The wrong man -- Trouble along the way -- The harder they fall -- Part III. Femme fatale -- Sentimental journey -- Beyond the sea -- Bewitched, bothered, and bewildered -- The girl from Ipanema -- Stormy weather -- House of the rising sun -- Can't we be friends? -- Fifty ways to leave your lover -- With a little help from my friends -- Sinnerman -- As time goes by

Father Christopher Hart, a young New York priest and classic film buff, is drafted by the mob to hear the confession of a man slated for execution. Should he just do his job and collaborate with the mob for the sake of souls or find a way to stop the violence?